Day 20 – Sugar Cookie Batter Cake Pops..The End!

I’ve wanted to make cake pops for a long time. My mom was kind enough to get me a mold for Christmas one year. The problem was that when I tried to find the mold, I couldn’t. I later realized that it’s still packed away in my baking supplies. A couple of days ago, I decided to go with it and just make them by hand. Wow, what an eventful, exhilarating process that really decided to test my patience! I wanted to do something different than your just traditional sugar cookie, so I decided to turn a similar type dough for a cookie into a cake batter and go from there. Let’s just say, I almost had a nervous breakdown trying to make these things, which is why I’m a day late and why Zach had to come save me from my very own self-destruction. These Sugar Cookie Batter Cake Pops are fun, delicious and the perfect recipe to end our series.

Do yourself a favor, if you have a mold…USE IT. Please dear God, just USE IT! Don’t put yourself through what I just put myself through. You will for sure regret it. Let’s be honest with each other, this is probably one of the hardest recipes I’ve ever tried to tackle. If I would have just stuck to your everyday cake pop recipe, I would have been more successful the first time around, but no, I just had to use a “sugar cookie” batter cake. What the heck is wrong with me? Thank God, Zach was there to save the day…AGAIN.

Zach to the rescue! … again …

Use the mold.

A couple of things before I share with you the musts for this recipe. If you don’t have patience, just forget it all together. You will laugh. You will cry. You will cry so hard you laugh, and laugh so hard you cry. Trust me. This does not take an hour to bake. It will actually probably take you at least a whole day (as in 24 hours) when all is said and done. I tried to rush it. I shouldn’t have. My first attempt ended in a goopey disastrous mess. I then cried and threw a fit, and Zach had to take over. Which he did, and he produced something pretty miraculous: beautiful cake pops exactly the way I had intended. Yay Zachy!

You will laugh and you will cry, but it will be worth it.


Be prepared before you start and go get everything you are going to need. This goes above and beyond edible ingredients and frilly decorations. Get your chocolates and melts. Get a large styrofoam block to stick your pops in to dry. Be sure you have lollipop sticks! IMPORTANT! It’s not a cake pop without a lollipop stick. Have something to package them in. I bought little treat bags from Michaels and wrapped a ribbon around them. Do this. It’s cheap and it’s a nice way to store them.

Be prepared!

Treat bags and ribbon are a nice added touch.

FOLLOW OUR DIRECTIONS! Don’t even try to skip a step. You will regret it. Make sure you let your chocolate drip off the pop. You will regret it if you don’t. Let everything chill exactly how we say to chill it, or you will most certainly regret it.

*Please Note* That it does not take over 12 hours to actually prep these, however it takes a ton of inactive time, so plan accordingly. It will take you a day or two to actually get an end product.

If…you…have…a…mold…use…it. It is not worth it to try to do it by hand. I don’t care what anyone tells you. Also: Some say that you shouldn’t refrigerate after your chocolate has hardened. They say the chocolate with crack. Maybe it has for some. I think this is bogus. I’ve done it and I’ve succeeded. They will last longer. I promise. Just be sure to let your chocolate completely harden before you put in the refrigerator. This is an important step if your storing them this way.

Follow the directions, but enjoy =)

Well, I have to say it’s been a fun run. I am ready to get back to pairing our favorite recipes with beer, but I do hope all of you have a Merry Christmas and/or Happy Holiday. It has been fun and I now have enough cookies to feed a small army, and I’m sure you all do too!

Happy Holidays!